Several upsets and some shake-up in the Top 25. With the first Playoff Rankings coming out this week, I start tracking unbeatens and my best bids for playoff contenders. Since Georgia won the SEC East this week, I will start tracking divisional and conference races next week.
Top 25 [Last week's position]
1. Georgia Bulldogs (8-0) [1]
2. Cincinnati Bearcats (8-0) [3] : They still didn't have a really decisive win, but losses among the Top 5 boosted them up
3. Ohio State Buckeyes (7-1) [4] : It was close against Penn State, but they buckled down in the fourth quarter and closed it out
4. Michigan State Spartans (8-0) [6] : I would not have guessed that the last remaining unbeaten team in the Big Ten would be the Spartans
5. Alabama Crimson Tide (7-1) [5]
6. Oklahoma Sooners (9-0) [7]
7. Wake Forest Demon Deacons (8-0) [9] : They seem to be getting stronger. It's the right time of the season for that.
8. Notre Dame Fighting Irish (7-1) [8]
9. Oregon Ducks (7-1) [10]
10. Michigan Wolverines (7-1) [2] : Too many mistakes cost them their unbeaten record, and may have cost them a shot at the playoffs
11. Oklahoma State Cowboys (7-1) [25] : Huge jump, combining their own performance and poor performances of other Top 25 teams
12. Auburn Tigers (6-2) [21]
13. Coastal Carolina Chanticleers (7-1) [15]
14. UTSA Roadrunners (8-0) [19]
15. Baylor Bears (7-1) [17]
16. Texas A&M Aggies (6-2) [16]
17. Houston Cougars (7-1) [20]
18. Penn State Nittany Lions (5-3) [18] : The only three-loss team in the Top 25, they played Ohio State tough
19. Iowa Hawkeyes (6-2) [12] : No offense
20. SMU Mustangs (7-1) [14]
21. NC State Wolfpack (6-2) [26] : A strong win brings them back into the rankings
22. Minnesota Golden Gophers (6-2) [NR] : The frontrunners to win the Big Ten West jump into the rankings
23. Louisiana Ragin Cajuns (7-1) [31]
24. Ole Miss Rebels (6-2) [13]
25. Kentucky Wildcats (6-2) [11]
On the Edge: Fresno State Bulldogs (7-2), Air Force Falcons (6-2), San Diego State Aztecs (7-1), Marshall Thundering Herd (5-3), Iowa State Cyclones (5-3), Pitt Panthers (6-2), BYU Cougars (7-2), Nevada Wolf Pack (6-2)
Dropped off: Arizona State Sun Devils [#22], Florida Gators [#23], San Diego State Aztecs [#24]
Big Ten Report
There were a few surprises this week. I didn't think the Ohio State - Penn State game would be so close. The comeback engineered by Michigan State surprised me. And I certainly didn't expect Wisconsin to have so much offensive success against Iowa's tough defense. The Badgers are definitely improving. Nebraska also played Purdue very close, which surprised me a bit.
Minnesota leads the West division, and they look strong enough to win it. Wisconsin is their only real competition, as Purdue still has games against Michigan State and Ohio State, so they will drop out of contention. Iowa's pathetic offense makes them a weak contender, as well.
Unbeatens and Playoff Contenders
We lost three unbeaten teams this week (Michigan, SMU, San Diego State), leaving us with just six. Five are in the Top Ten, and UTSA moved up to #14. The Roadrunners don't have a chance to be considered for the playoffs, but how do the others fare? Georgia is likely in, unless they lose the SEC Championship (which doesn't seem likely). If Michigan State wins out, and wins the Big Ten title, they are in. If Ohio State beats them, they're out. How about the others?
Cincinnati needs style points or some help from the Oklahoma State Cowboys. See, unbeaten champions of both the ACC and Big XII will likely trump Cincinnati's bid. However, if Oklahoma State beats their in-state rivals, either later this season or in the Big XII title game, that prevents the Big XII champ from going unbeaten. Given the shape of the ACC this season, Wake seems unlikely to lose. However, also given the overall weakness of the conference, is their performance good enough to jump over Cincinnati? Only if they continue to improve. The Demon Deacons have been more dominant in the past couple of weeks. Ending the season like that would give them the boost needed to jump over Cincinnati.
So what is the most likely source of the four playoff teams? The SEC champion is in, without a doubt. Given the strength of the Big Ten this season, that champ is in (unless the champ somehow has two losses). An unbeaten Big XII champ will get in, but can Oklahoma beat Oklahoma State TWICE in the same season? Now, if the COWBOYS beat the Sooners twice, or the Cowboys win out (regardless of who they might face in the Big XII title game), then a one-loss Oklahoma State team seems likely. Cincinnati is in if Oklahoma loses or if Wake Forest doesn't dominate anymore. At this point of the season, based upon what I have seen, here is my best guess: Georgia #1 seed, Ohio State #2 seed, Cincinnati #3 seed, Wake Forest #4 seed. Yes, you saw that last position correctly. I don't think the Big XII champ gets in, as I see both Oklahoma and Oklahoma State (and Baylor, for that matter) losing, likely to each other.
What would be a true "monkey wrench" in this entire affair? If Georgia loses the SEC Championship to a one-loss Alabama team. Then both Georgia and Alabama will be in with Ohio State and ONE of Cincinnati and Wake Forest.
Upset Report
Although we didn't have too many upsets that affected Top 25 teams, we were rife with them this weekend. Obviously we started with the Michigan State victory, followed quickly by Miami's overthrow of Pitt and Bowling Green beating Buffalo. That MAC continues to confound me!
The Pac-12 suffered two upsets. Washington State knocked off Arizona State, and knocked them right out of the rankings. Then the Cal Golden Bears dominated Oregon State. Conference USA also had two upsets, as Charlotte was smothered by Western Kentucky and floundering Florida Atlantic rose up against one-loss UTEP.
Perhaps the biggest upset, though, was located in the SEC. Kentucky, a strong one-loss team, was facing unranked Mississippi State, whose record was only 3-4. The Wildcats could never get it together, and the Bulldogs just blew them away. As you see at the beginning of this column, that has put Kentucky's ranking in jeopardy.